STILL HUMAN: A story of leading though AI
Preface:
Across business right now, AI is moving quickly from discussion to direction.
In leadership teams, it is no longer a future conversation. It is a present one. There is pressure to understand it, adopt it, encourage it, and work out how it fits into the rhythm of everyday business. We can hear the voices in the boardrooms ... “Use it to save time”, “Use it to improve efficiency”, “Use it to help teams move faster”. “Use it to show that the organisation is keeping pace.”
For many senior leaders, especially those responsible for people, culture and change, that creates a very real tension. Not because they cannot see the opportunity, but because they can. They can see the possibility in it, the pressure around it, and they can also feel the uncertainty sitting quietly underneath it all.
This story centres on a leader standing in that exact space.
Her name is Sarah.
The Story:
It’s not stopping…
Sarah had lost count of how many times AI had come up in conversation that month.
It was in board meetings, leadership calls, strategy sessions, and those slightly more honest chats that happen when the formal meeting ends and people begin saying what they really think.
Sometimes AI was spoken about with excitement, sometimes with urgency, sometimes with a confidence that felt just a little, well ... ahead of reality.
“Use it to improve productivity”, “Use it to save time”, “Use it to help teams move faster”, “Use it to show that the business is moving with the times.”
The message was clear enough.
AI was no longer something interesting to watch from the side-lines. It was becoming something leaders were expected to support, shape and embed. And as People Director, Sarah knew that expectation would increasingly find its way to her. That was the role, after all.
When something this significant begins changing how people work, think and feel, it does not stay in the world of systems and process for long. It becomes a people conversation, culture conversation, trust conversation, safety conversation ... a leadership conversation.
Which meant, whether she liked it or not, Sarah was now standing somewhere near the centre of it.
The strange thing was, she was not against it. In truth, part of her felt hopeful. She could see the opportunity in reducing friction, helping people move through certain tasks more efficiently, and creating a bit more space for better thinking. She could imagine AI being genuinely useful when used well. She could see the potential in removing some of the clutter that so often fills modern working life.
But alongside that hope sat something heavier. Not resistance, but responsibility.
Because Sarah also knew that when businesses move quickly, it is often the human nuance that gets lost first. Beyond the powerpoint and corporate jargon, people will still be sitting there quietly wondering … what this means for them?
There would be the questions on AI that she knew would not be raised publicly, but they would be there … What happens if I do not understand AI quickly enough? What if I get left behind? What if parts of what I do are suddenly seen as less valuable? What if leadership starts pushing this forward before we have really thought about what it means for people?
And being honest with herself … some of these questions lived in her too.
But this wasn’t because she thought AI was the problem. It was because she knew the challenge was bigger than adoption. The challenge was how to help an organisation move towards something new without losing the humanity that made work feel connected, trusting and real in the first place.
This was her conundrum.
She was not wrestling with whether AI should be part of the future, she was wrestling with how, what and why.
How do we begin in a way that brings people with us?
What are we really trying to improve?
Why does this matter beyond simply moving faster?
And perhaps most importantly, how do we stop this becoming a story people fear, rather than one they can find their place within?
A quiet place…
One evening, after another long day of conversations that felt certain on the surface and uncertain underneath, Sarah sat at her kitchen table with a notebook open in front of her. The house was quiet, and her laptop was closed for once. No presentations, no leadership papers, no clever frameworks, just a blank page and the thoughts she had not quite had time to hear properly all week.
At the top of the page, she wrote a single question.
Where do we begin? … She sat with that question for a while.
The more she thought about it, the more she realised the answer could not start with policy, platforms, targets or training plans. Those things would matter, of course. But they were not the beginning. Not really.
The beginning was people.
What story were people already telling themselves about AI? For some, perhaps it was a story of excitement. A chance to learn, improve and evolve. For others, perhaps it was a story of fear. Fear of becoming less relevant, of not being good enough, of not knowing enough, of being replaced. For many, perhaps it was both at once.
And if those stories were already alive inside the business, then leadership’s job was not simply to drive adoption. It was to understand the story people were already in, and help shape a better one. A story in which AI was not positioned as a threat to human value, but as a tool that could support it. A story in which efficiency did not come at the expense of empathy. A story in which progress did not mean people had to leave their humanity at the door. A story in which leaders did not pretend to have all the answers, but were willing to ask better questions.
That realisation did not give Sarah a polished plan. It did not suddenly produce the framework, roadmap or answer that would satisfy every voice around the boardroom table. In truth, it made the challenge feel bigger.
But it also gave her something important … a footing.
Perhaps the path forward was not to begin with AI as a tool, but with AI as a human experience. To recognise that for all the talk of productivity and capability, people would make sense of this change emotionally before they made sense of it operationally. They would filter it through safety, trust, confidence, identity, experience and fear.
That is where storytelling mattered.
Storytelling gave Sarah a way of thinking about the challenge that felt more grounded and more true. It brought her back to people, perspective and meaning. It reminded her that before leaders can ask people to engage with change, they need to understand how that change feels from where those people are standing.
It also reminded her that leadership does not always begin with certainty, sometimes it begins with honesty and vulnerability. With the willingness to say, we may not have all the answers yet, but we do need to begin in the right place. With the courage to resist rushing straight to the tool, and instead ask what kind of future people need help believing in.
Sarah did not yet know exactly what the journey would look like. She did not have the polished roadmap or the perfect response. But what she did know was this … If the organisation started with speed before understanding, pressure before perspective, or tools before trust, it would get the footing wrong.
And in a world moving quickly towards AI, perhaps that was one of the most important realisations of all.
Not that leaders need to know everything before they begin … but that they need to begin in a way that is …
… still human.
Story Takeaways:
Sarah’s story reflects a tension many HR and executive leaders are now carrying.
The challenge is not simply whether to adopt AI. In many organisations, that question has already been answered. The challenge is how to help people move towards it in a way that feels thoughtful, safe, trusted and human.
That is what makes this moment more than a technology conversation. It is a leadership conversation, a culture conversation, a people conversation.
AI may bring speed, efficiency and possibility, and these things matter. But for the leaders sitting closest to the human impact of change, there is another layer to consider. How will this land? What story are people already telling themselves? What fears are sitting quietly beneath the surface? What hopes are waiting to be unlocked if this is handled well?
This is where storytelling becomes so important.
Storytelling helps leaders step back from the noise of adoption and reconnect with the human reality of transition. It encourages better questions. Who is this change really affecting? How might it feel from their side? What meaning are they making from what is being said and done? How do we communicate progress without creating distance?
In that sense, storytelling is not just a communication technique. It is one of the disciplines that helps leaders find the right footing in times of uncertainty.
Sarah did not solve the challenge in one neat moment, and that is part of what makes her story relatable. Most leaders are not looking for a perfect answer, they are looking for a way to begin well. A way to move forward without losing trust, tone and humanity in the process.
And perhaps that is the real work here … Not just embedding AI, but shaping the story around it in a way people can step into.
Reflection Question:
As AI becomes more present in your organisation, where might the pressure to move faster be pulling attention away from the human story that people are living through?
Helping you GROW through storytelling
Whether it be for yourself or for your business, let’s work together to improve impact, create meaningful connections, drive positive change, and GROW…
Products and Services include:
Personalised 1:1 coaching | Workshops and Seminars | Speaking
Specific Projects | Fractional Support
Bestselling books > Learn more here
Get in touch:
email: jamie@jamie-mackenzie.com
join the allotment for growth based insights: the allotment
